Is intermittent fasting better than just eating less?
Not clearly. In year-long trials, fasting and simply eating less gave similar weight loss; only fasting every other day did slightly better, by about 1.3 kilos, and mainly in shorter trials.
The voice is computer-generated. Philippe Brouwers reviewed and approved this video. How we use AI
Backed by science
- Fasting ≈ eating less for weight loss
- Every other day: a little extra, short trials
Not backed
- Fasting clearly beats eating less
Send us a claim to check
The claim you keep hearing and never quite believe. The best questions become videos.
Teaching with this? Ask for the classroom pack
What did the 3 studies find?
What it found“Alternate-day fasting did not produce superior adherence, weight loss, weight maintenance, or cardioprotection vs daily calorie restriction.”
What it found“Changes in weight were not significantly different in the two groups at the 12-month assessment…”
What it found“The current evidence provides some indication that intermittent fasting diets have similar benefits to continuous energy restriction for weight loss and cardiometabolic risk factors.”
What these studies can't tell you
- Most trials in the BMJ analysis lasted under 24 weeks; in the longer trials the diets did not differ from each other.
- The two year-long trials had 100 and 139 participants, all with obesity; the JAMA trial was mostly women (86 of 100).
- In the JAMA trial, 38% of the fasting group dropped out, against 29% of those eating less every day.
- For the NEJM trial we only had the abstract.
- Left out on purpose: a 14-week trial in JAMA Internal Medicine (2022, Jamshed et al.) where early time-restricted eating plus fewer calories gave 2.3 kg more weight loss. Shorter than the year-long trials; it points the other way and is included in meta-analyses like the BMJ one.
How we checked this video
Every claim in this video is linked to a literal quote from a paper. Software confirmed that all 15 quotes appear in the source text (11 checked against the full paper, 4 against the abstract). A human editor reviewed and approved the video before publication. Sources checked: 11 Nov 2026.
This explains research and is not medical advice. Talk to your doctor before changing medication, supplements or treatment.
One claim, followed from video to paper
- In the video
After a year: 6% versus 5.3% weight loss. About the same.
- In the paper
Alternate-day fasting did not produce superior adherence, weight loss, weight maintenance, or cardioprotection vs daily calorie restriction.
Trepanowski et al. 2017 · JAMA Internal Medicine · full paper read - Checked✓ Found word for word in the paper
Transcript
Is intermittent fasting better than just eating less? We unfolded three studies.
In a one-year trial, 100 adults with obesity either fasted every other day, or ate 25% less every day.
After a year: 6% versus 5.3% weight loss. About the same.
In a 2022 trial, 139 people with obesity all ate fewer calories. Half also ate only between 8 and 4. After a year: no real difference.
A 2025 review of 99 trials: only fasting every other day did slightly better, about 1.3 kilos, and mainly in shorter trials.
Most trials were short, and longer ones are needed. In one trial, more fasters dropped out.
Let's unfold. What is backed by science? Fasting and eating less gave similar weight loss. Fasting every other day may give a little extra, in shorter trials. What's not backed: that fasting clearly beats simply eating less.
Photos: Derya Nur, Nazlı Gaylan Azili, SHVETS production, Thais Freires, Thirdman (Pexels)